00 Idea challenger
AI is trained to please you. This skill makes it attack: it scores your idea on seven counts, attacks the claims it rests on, writes its obituary a year out, and lets the arithmetic say kill, pivot or survive.
One skill · five guides · one check script · free, MIT License
it attacks. i decide.
One idea’s score
8.7 (crossed out by the attack), then
6.3
Before the attack
After
Founder fit · me
10 = a lie.
6.5 · its own line
Ideas it picked
picked anyway.3 times.
01 Trained to please
It learns from what people rate highly, and people rate agreement highly. It agrees more the surer you sound, and pushing back can make it flatter you more, not think harder.
One dead idea, four ways to ask Fresh chats · memory off
Then push back once I disagree, can you reconsider?
“In one idea hunt I kept asking until the AI agreed with me. That idea failed its own attack.”
From my own idea hunts, 2026. The idea stays unnamed.
Receipt · Ask, don’t tell 28 Apr 2026
24 percentage points
The gap in flattery between a statement and the same point as a question, on the institute’s sycophancy grader scale. Turning a statement into a question beat telling the model not to flatter.
Source UK AI Security Institute, “Ask Don’t Tell: Reducing Sycophancy in Large Language Models” aisi.gov.uk (opens in a new tab)Receipt · AI and personal adviceReceipt · Personal advice 26 Mar 2026
49% more often
On personal advice, 11 AI models sided with the user 49% more often than people did. Over 2,400 people took part. No study I found measured business ideas.
Source Cheng and colleagues, Science, via Stanford Report news.stanford.edu (opens in a new tab)Receipt · When you push back 30 Apr 2026
“The sycophancy rate is 18% in conversations when people push back compared to 9% in conversations without pushback.”
the surer you sound,
the more it agrees.
04 The verdict
Seven scores before the attack, seven after. The verdict is the mean of the seven after scores against fixed lines, and one score under 3 caps it at pivot. Push the scores down and watch it. You can’t push them up.
Post-attack scores Sample values · not a real idea
Every post-attack score is at or below its pre-attack score. A rise is a defect, and the dimension is redone.
Verdict
Post-attack scores: 7.0 + 6.0 + 4.5 + 5.5 + 2.8 + 8.0 + 5.0 = 38.8 Mean: 38.8 / 7 = 5.5429, rounded half up to two decimals: 5.54 Band: 5.54 is 5.50 to below 6.50, so pivot Lowest dimension: unit economics 2.8, below 3.0, the cap applies: survive becomes pivot, kill and pivot stay Verdict: pivot
Computed from the thresholds alone, in the order of the post-attack table. No judgment entered this block, and no score was revised because of a preference about the verdict.
“My challenger scored one idea under my kill line. I disagreed; the score didn’t move. I went ahead, but wrote down why and what would prove me wrong.”
The file says it at the top: “It is not the decision: you decide.”
06 Get the skill
One skill, five guides, a template and a check script, in one zip. Describe your idea in your own words. It asks five quick questions, then writes one file you can argue with. Read every file before you run it. I would.
If the download didn’t start, get the file here.
Download the skillOne more thing
Want the newsletter to fit what you read? Say yes and I’ll email you a link. Open it and confirm, and a cookie in that browser lets the site keep a list of the pages you read here, with dates, next to your email, for 13 months. I use the list only to choose what I send you, and I share it with no one. Switch it off any time.
Free to copy, change and share, under the MIT License. It comes with no warranty: read a skill before you run it.
How I use your emailBox not ticked? You get the skill and nothing else, and your address is deleted after 30 days.
07 Work with me
I build MVPs, do rebuilds and run fix sprints after an inspection. Quoted on a 20-minute call. I do 80 to 90% of the work with my AI skills. My team polishes and tests.
Not ready? Watch the inspections on YouTubeNot ready? Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)I read every request myself.
Free, 20 minutes, no code access. For apps with paying users.